Imagine leaving Celtic for Burnley? Ryan Christie’s money versus glory dilemma

Winning Captains

Administrator
Staff member
Initially I thought Charlie Christie was upping the ante in the contract negotiations, rather than actually believing his boy was ready for the Prem. Now I’m not so sure. Burnley makes sense as they are a direct team, full of endeavour and lacking in subtlety.

Christie remains undisciplined in shape, lazy in his passing on too many occasions and now his ability to shoot from distance is diminishing. I think he’d do well to focus on sharpening those areas while playing for Celtic and if he did his big move would see him move to a more technically proficient team.

He’s more than capable but I don’t see real development from his game in the last few months, it’s like he has plateaued somewhat. Perhaps he needs to get back to improving and tightening his game up. He’s better than Burnley but at the moment I don’t see anyone else risking putting Ryan in their team when he’s lost sight a little of the basics.

He is capable of going to the top but he needs to get back to the nuts and bolts. Perhaps the speculation impacts on his performances. Maybe he listens to his Dad a bit too much. Charlie is a big man in Inverness. He didn’t have the head for not being a big fish in a small pond. Ryan needs to look elsewhere than him for career advice.
 
Imagine a player leaving Celtic for Southampton?
About the same size club.
End of the day if Burnley match Celtics asking price and he wants to go he'll go.

His Da will see Burnley as a stepping stone to a bigger EPL club.
Maybe NFL should let him play in his place instead of relying on him as a striker when there's 3 strikers on the bench and one at home
 
19 goals for a midfielder is good going, 15-20 million would be about right, still has 2 years left on his contract, time everyone realised we’re a selling club, once the buying club hits the right price EVERYONES for sale, I have no issues with that, frankly we need the money, especially in this Covid-19 hit season, there are others waiting for a free space in what is a busy midfield area, Soro, Turnbull, rodgic etc
 
19 goals for a midfielder is good going, 15-20 million would be about right, still has 2 years left on his contract, time everyone realised we’re a selling club, once the buying club hits the right price EVERYONES for sale, I have no issues with that, frankly we need the money, especially in this Covid-19 hit season, there are others waiting for a free space in what is a busy midfield area, Soro, Turnbull, rodgic etc
👍👍
 
Initially I thought Charlie Christie was upping the ante in the contract negotiations, rather than actually believing his boy was ready for the Prem. Now I’m not so sure. Burnley makes sense as they are a direct team, full of endeavour and lacking in subtlety.

Christie remains undisciplined in shape, lazy in his passing on too many occasions and now his ability to shoot from distance is diminishing. I think he’d do well to focus on sharpening those areas while playing for Celtic and if he did his big move would see him move to a more technically proficient team.

He’s more than capable but I don’t see real development from his game in the last few months, it’s like he has plateaued somewhat. Perhaps he needs to get back to improving and tightening his game up. He’s better than Burnley but at the moment I don’t see anyone else risking putting Ryan in their team when he’s lost sight a little of the basics.

He is capable of going to the top but he needs to get back to the nuts and bolts. Perhaps the speculation impacts on his performances. Maybe he listens to his Dad a bit too much. Charlie is a big man in Inverness. He didn’t have the head for not being a big fish in a small pond. Ryan needs to look elsewhere than him for career advice.
Cant agree with that. He has been shooting more from outside the box because we have been playing pish and our final ball and all round play in the last third has been awful. He has had to take shots he wouldn't normally do for the reasons above. It just hasn't been working and he has done more n the gams so far than Forrest or Brown. Who up until now have regressed to ineffective at best and a hindrance to progress by doing fuck all. Brown ws better against His but he still has a way to go to keep Turnbull or Sort out for me. I like Christie and feel he is just suffering from the overall tepid form. I would keep him and don't think he has plateaued he's just part of a team that so far haven't even touched on top form.
 
Cant agree with that. He has been shooting more from outside the box because we have been playing pish and our final ball and all round play in the last third has been awful. He has had to take shots he wouldn't normally do for the reasons above. It just hasn't been working and he has done more n the gams so far than Forrest or Brown. Who up until now have regressed to ineffective at best and a hindrance to progress by doing fuck all. Brown ws better against His but he still has a way to go to keep Turnbull or Sort out for me. I like Christie and feel he is just suffering from the overall tepid form. I would keep him and don't think he has plateaued he's just part of a team that so far haven't even touched on top form.
Fair enough TV. I rate Christie highly, it's my opinion though that he's lost sight of the basics a little. It's not just the shooting, short range passing had also gone askew somewhat, though as you say he is far from the only one.
Forrest and Christie both have valid excuses for being shipped from position to position and that can of course take its toll. The stop start nature to the season possibly also hasn’t helped either player but if - and it’s rumoured of course rather than factual - that contract negotiations may have stalled as he eyes the Premier League I think he could do better than the likes of Burnley if he was consistent with the basics.
His form up to December ish in 2019 was superb, he hasn’t been as dynamic since and I can handle that as he’d be hard pushed to maintain the consistency but until that 45 mins against Hibs he appeared off it. Mind you there seemed a general staleness in that midfield, even Calmac had an off moment or two.
Perhaps the signing – and what a 45 mins btw – of Turnbull may be enough to snap some including Christie out of that malaise. Forrest injured or not will find it hard to dislodge Frimpong and I could see a similar energy returning to the centre of the park if Soro was afforded more game time.
Brown I’ve held back on as he’s often a little slow to get up to speed, but even taking that into account he’s been behind the pace of the game until Sunday and the number of bookings he’s had have ben indicative of a player off the pace at times.
Whether Brown hits top form or not he cannot play as often throughout the season as he has until now, it’s not sustainable any longer, it’s not fair on his legacy and we need to plan for succession and Soro will need time to find his own way of operating in the team and have the other players around him get used to his style.
When Lennon got subbed in that Cup final by Strachan for Caldwell it showed sometimes players can’t decide for themselves, as such Lenny will have to fade the player out slowly, Soro looks a player to me, I’d like to see more of him. Maybe we will when the window closes and we know what we have for the season ahead.
 
Cant agree with that. He has been shooting more from outside the box because we have been playing pish and our final ball and all round play in the last third has been awful. He has had to take shots he wouldn't normally do for the reasons above. It just hasn't been working and he has done more n the gams so far than Forrest or Brown. Who up until now have regressed to ineffective at best and a hindrance to progress by doing fuck all. Brown ws better against His but he still has a way to go to keep Turnbull or Sort out for me. I like Christie and feel he is just suffering from the overall tepid form. I would keep him and don't think he has plateaued he's just part of a team that so far haven't even touched on top form.
(y)
RC is a top player

We hav sum attackin midfield options, best 4 a long time
MO - RC - TURNBULL - CALMAC (his most efftiv positin) - ROGIC - LUCA - MIKEY - HENDO N Jamesy.

But!
if only we had more dan Broony as a proper defensiv ball winning midfield
(Mayb Soro but is he ever gonna get a chance?)

Wiv a few tweaks 2 d system & a proper LWB signd
Celtic wud b knockin 6 plus past poor teams like 2nite n B a Team able 4 Europe & d SPFL
 
(y)
RC is a top player

We hav sum attackin midfield options, best 4 a long time
MO - RC - TURNBULL - CALMAC (his most efftiv positin) - ROGIC - wiv LUCA - MIKEY - HENDO N Jamesy.

But!
if only we had more dan Broony as a proper defensiv ball winning midfield
(Mayb Soro but is he ever gonna get a chance?)

Wiv a few tweaks 2 d system & a proper LWB signd
Celtic wud b knockin 6 plus past poor teams like 2nite n a Team able 4 Europe & d SPFL
Who the fuvk is dan broon is that big hens brother😂😂😂😂😂
 
Fair enough TV. I rate Christie highly, it's my opinion though that he's lost sight of the basics a little. It's not just the shooting, short range passing had also gone askew somewhat, though as you say he is far from the only one.
Forrest and Christie both have valid excuses for being shipped from position to position and that can of course take its toll. The stop start nature to the season possibly also hasn’t helped either player but if - and it’s rumoured of course rather than factual - that contract negotiations may have stalled as he eyes the Premier League I think he could do better than the likes of Burnley if he was consistent with the basics.
His form up to December ish in 2019 was superb, he hasn’t been as dynamic since and I can handle that as he’d be hard pushed to maintain the consistency but until that 45 mins against Hibs he appeared off it. Mind you there seemed a general staleness in that midfield, even Calmac had an off moment or two.
Perhaps the signing – and what a 45 mins btw – of Turnbull may be enough to snap some including Christie out of that malaise. Forrest injured or not will find it hard to dislodge Frimpong and I could see a similar energy returning to the centre of the park if Soro was afforded more game time.
Brown I’ve held back on as he’s often a little slow to get up to speed, but even taking that into account he’s been behind the pace of the game until Sunday and the number of bookings he’s had have ben indicative of a player off the pace at times.
Whether Brown hits top form or not he cannot play as often throughout the season as he has until now, it’s not sustainable any longer, it’s not fair on his legacy and we need to plan for succession and Soro will need time to find his own way of operating in the team and have the other players around him get used to his style.
When Lennon got subbed in that Cup final by Strachan for Caldwell it showed sometimes players can’t decide for themselves, as such Lenny will have to fade the player out slowly, Soro looks a player to me, I’d like to see more of him. Maybe we will when the window closes and we know what we have for the season ahead.
Good post enjoyed that. Christie is a class player and as we know, bringing a young guy with ability ups everybody's game. Soro is the real deal, he.s ready to step in, he wont but he is.
 
Back
Top