Would u take Mcgeady for a season

Alexander6788

Active member
welcome to the noise watch out for the night shift

Roberts was valued a £4'5m when we were interested in him his value on transfermarket have dropped to 2.5m looks like they loan moves worked wonders for him
would take him back in a heartbeat
No worries jelly thanks for the shout and his loans never worked out a read that and he has some injury problems I would hope he could get rid because when he was with us he was a player and when fit he can terroriynost defences up here so he could be worth a punt
 

Khenny

Well-known member
I was never a big fan of McGeady even in his youth. Not questioning that the kid had talent, but definitely questioning his use of that talent.

Considering the number of times he was given the ball by his teammates he was incredibly wasteful with it. Very occasionally he'd pull off a piece of unbelievable skill and then everyone would scream about how he was the best thing since sliced bread.

Those moments were fleeting but are indelibly etched in the memories of fans that idolised him. I've not looked at his stats but I would doubt if they even come close to what Jamesy have achieved, especially when it comes to assists.
 

Tenerife tim

Well-known member
I was never a big fan of McGeady even in his youth. Not questioning that the kid had talent, but definitely questioning his use of that talent.

Considering the number of times he was given the ball by his teammates he was incredibly wasteful with it. Very occasionally he'd pull off a piece of unbelievable skill and then everyone would scream about how he was the best thing since sliced bread.

Those moments were fleeting but are indelibly etched in the memories of fans that idolised him. I've not looked at his stats but I would doubt if they even come close to what Jamesy have achieved, especially when it comes to assists.
Absolutely bang on khenny. Laughed like a drain when the mad ruskies gave us 9million for him ,unbelievable when you think we paid the same for eddy. Peter stashed it for a decade, bought eddy and trousered the interest as a wee bonus for himself. Shrewd fker that he is HH
 

Khenny

Well-known member
Absolutely bang on khenny. Laughed like a drain when the mad ruskies gave us 9million for him ,unbelievable when you think we paid the same for eddy. Peter stashed it for a decade, bought eddy and trousered the interest as a wee bonus for himself. Shrewd fker that he is HH
I actually remember being quite embarrassed when they spent £9m on him.

I thought it would reflect badly on us when they figured out he was grossly overrated and subsequently we wouldn't be able to command top dollar for any of our future development kids came along.
 

Tony Soprano

Well-known member
I was never a big fan of McGeady even in his youth. Not questioning that the kid had talent, but definitely questioning his use of that talent.

Considering the number of times he was given the ball by his teammates he was incredibly wasteful with it. Very occasionally he'd pull off a piece of unbelievable skill and then everyone would scream about how he was the best thing since sliced bread.

Those moments were fleeting but are indelibly etched in the memories of fans that idolised him. I've not looked at his stats but I would doubt if they even come close to what Jamesy have achieved, especially when it comes to assists.
Best youth player in Scotland at one time .Mind the Milan players giving him praise after a game at Parkhead years ago.Hes had a decent career and made alot of money but he could have been even better
 

kelly

Well-known member
Best youth player in Scotland at one time .Mind the Milan players giving him praise after a game at Parkhead years ago.Hes had a decent career and made alot of money but he could have been even better
Milan players couldn't believe how easy it was to take the ball from him,and stood in amazement at him going after lenny for a rammy

got to hand it to him he had an ego ,,,,a big one
 

Khenny

Well-known member
Best youth player in Scotland at one time .Mind the Milan players giving him praise after a game at Parkhead years ago.Hes had a decent career and made alot of money but he could have been even better
If memory serves he skinned Maldini once during the game on the far side of the pitch but that was about all he did.

If one game ever encapsulated someone's career then that might've been the game for McGreedy. (see what I did there?) Five seconds of skill and 89mins 55secs of mediocrity.

Just my opinion mind you, but I reckon he's one of the most overrated payers ever to wear the Hoops.
 

Tony Soprano

Well-known member
If memory serves he skinned Maldini once during the game on the far side of the pitch but that was about all he did.

If one game ever encapsulated someone's career then that might've been the game for McGreedy. (see what I did there?) Five seconds of skill and 89mins 55secs of mediocrity.

Just my opinion mind you, but I reckon he's one of the most overrated payers ever to wear the Hoops.
so the players approached him for 1 bit of skill ?ok 😂dont think it was Maldini he skinned ,could be wrong right enough
 

Khenny

Well-known member
Clearly telling him he played well you know exactly what i meant smart arse
I'm not trying to be a smart arse m8.

You mentioned it as if something extraordinary had taken place.

In almost every game that's ever taken place players congratulate opponents for playing well. I was genuinely wondering what I'd failed to remember about his performance that night that made it different.

I take it you're referring to the 2-1 game when McDonald scored the late winner?
 

Members online

Latest posts

Top