Why an SPFL Play-off Solution is the Quick-Fix to all Neil Doncaster's Problems

Winning Captains

Winning Captains

Administrator
Staff member
Why an SPFL Play-off Solution is the Quick-Fix to all Neil Doncaster's Problems...

In this article I talk about the SFL and how the Rangers ended up with the old club's honours. Would like to know if you were aware of this happening as described or not?

thecelticstar.com

Why an SPFL Play-off Solution is the Quick-Fix to all Neil Doncaster's Problems | The Celtic Star

PARTICK THISTLE and Inverness Caley Thistle voted against the SPFL proposal yesterday and alongside Hearts, Falkirk and Stranraer and you can see why. All these clubs are unnecessarily losing out and
thecelticstar.com thecelticstar.com
 
Winning Captains Bolingoli said:
Why an SPFL Play-off Solution is the Quick-Fix to all Neil Doncaster's Problems...

In this article I talk about the SFL and how the Rangers ended up with the old club's honours. Would like to know if you were aware of this happening as described or not?

thecelticstar.com

Why an SPFL Play-off Solution is the Quick-Fix to all Neil Doncaster's Problems | The Celtic Star

PARTICK THISTLE and Inverness Caley Thistle voted against the SPFL proposal yesterday and alongside Hearts, Falkirk and Stranraer and you can see why. All these clubs are unnecessarily losing out and
thecelticstar.com thecelticstar.com
Click to expand...
Explained well and seems to cover all bases as I seen the shambles leading to 2012 then after.

didn't now about celtic points deduction for miss registered player though.

The culture they hold for some people allows them to project their failings at others and take credit for stuff which would otherwise be classed as cheating.

one rule for the peepo

another rule for people the peepo decide are not peepo

special dispensations are afforded to peepo who have been declared peepo by ra peepo.

Its an ancient anglo Saxon thing, imo

reinstituted during the Neo anglo Saxon Hanoverians
 
Last edited:
Doncaster will have never learned the lesson - that by pandering to the whims of sevco and the klan, then they now own him for life.

There was never going to be a solution which would find universal approval, but if Dundee return a vote favourable to the minority, then Doncaster will run rings around himself trying to find a a bluenose-friendly answer that just doesn't exist!

The ideal scenario for sevco is to have the prize money distributed in line with the current league placings, but to have the season declared null and void. These two features cannot exist in the same universe, but try explaining that to the fans of a club who let their former club spiral down the sinkhole in 2012 and still believe that that didn't happen.

Like the huns of old, they have absolutely no concept of long-term planning. They jeopardise all European places allocated to Scottish football based on their very, very narrow tunnel vision. Celtic will survive without European football, it's debatable whether that mob can even splutter through their current situation with European football - they'd be on extremely thin ice without it. Any preferred outcome of this whole debacle is only intended to impede Celtic, it is not intended to promote their own circumstances.

As far as I'm concerned, let them play their silly games. Regardless of the outcome, it's still a lose-lose for them. There are NO outcomes available that work out favourably for them.
 
I like the idea of the play off solution in theory. I’d hope we’d use the Scottish cup semi’s and final as a curtain raiser to the new season (whenever that may be) and the same could be done for these clubs.

One issue the clubs may have is the uncertainty. Season tickets will be priced differently for different divisions so couldn’t be sold until that was decided. Sponsorship is also likely to vary dependent on which division the club is in so it’s difficult to pitch for that. That said the SPFL could easily step in and bridge those concerns financially.

In terms of reconstruction, I’d be all for it but not a sticking plaster approach for a season and a return to a status quo that- from the TCS debate - showed there was no appetite for prior to all of this.

This week’s SPFL proposal gave a provision for protecting positions for now, distributing prize money and then having time to debate a long standing restructure option while we waited for the season to start. God knows it’s evident when they couldn’t even agree how to vote on this, or even to vote at all that our clubs would take sometime to agree on the colour of s***e never mind a restructure.
 
There is one easy solution get Park and the rest of the mouthpieces to man up,tell thier supports that the club is in deep trouble and they like other clubs need the money now and it is no use sticking thier heads in the sand and thinking there is a chance of them winning the league,

That is what they should do but they won't they haven't the guts to do it in fear that that thier bigots will tear into them, they would rather bluff it out to keep the mugs happy,Sad isn't it
 
The quick solution is no relegation. Promote 2 and relegate 0 and play 20/21 season with 14, 10, 10, 10.
Once agreed then work over the next 3 months, ie up to when next season begins (at the earliest) and decide if we return to leagues of 12, 10, 10, 10 or have a permanent new league set.
Personally I’m of the opinion we have too many professional teams for a small (and in footballing terms poor) country and we should look at a top flight of 14 teams (split at halfway stage to 2 x 7) and a second tier of 20. All teams play 38 games.
Below the top two tiers there is a regional pyramid set up for part time, semi pro clubs who have an avenue to progress up to the upper 2 professional tiers.
 
Spherical Planet said:
Doncaster will have never learned the lesson - that by pandering to the whims of sevco and the klan, then they now own him for life.

There was never going to be a solution which would find universal approval, but if Dundee return a vote favourable to the minority, then Doncaster will run rings around himself trying to find a a bluenose-friendly answer that just doesn't exist!

The ideal scenario for sevco is to have the prize money distributed in line with the current league placings, but to have the season declared null and void. These two features cannot exist in the same universe, but try explaining that to the fans of a club who let their former club spiral down the sinkhole in 2012 and still believe that that didn't happen.

Like the huns of old, they have absolutely no concept of long-term planning. They jeopardise all European places allocated to Scottish football based on their very, very narrow tunnel vision. Celtic will survive without European football, it's debatable whether that mob can even splutter through their current situation with European football - they'd be on extremely thin ice without it. Any preferred outcome of this whole debacle is only intended to impede Celtic, it is not intended to promote their own circumstances.

As far as I'm concerned, let them play their silly games. Regardless of the outcome, it's still a lose-lose for them. There are NO outcomes available that work out favourably for them.
Click to expand...
Micheal Stewart talking shite regards the SPFL been a members association and as such they can just change rules and pay out, i beg to differ the SPFL is a registered company and as such are held to their rules and regulations as set when club enter into contract, to change on the whim will have legal consequences, guys like daryll broadfoot compain about teams bringing lawyers to appeals as if it burdens the SPFL, but the fact remains when a company, then a company is held to company law amd members are allowed legal representation and any decisions to change or ammend rules are open to legal challenge, this is why sevco and hearts are using the legislation and threat of legal action, so Micheal Stewart taliking about just give out prize money is talking shite, prize money is based on positions only if a league is called or completed, so as it stands all club are in an equal poistion in the kitty if not called/ ended and if ended comes with relegation and champions.

THE SCOTTISH PROFESSIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE LIMITED


Company number SC175364

Registered office address Hampden Park, Glasgow, G42 9DE
Company status Active

Company type Private limited Company Incorporated on 13 May 1997
 
Last edited:
Club claiming that it's email was not recieved although sent.
If you send an email and it does not recieve it bounces back as not sent
So did Dundee send it to the wrong address if it never pinged back.
Thats how emails work the address is either valid or not

so who did they send it to what address
if it is the wrong address then it was not recieved
if it was the wrong formation or invalid address it would ping back
Bullshit
 
boab1916 said:
Club claiming that it's email was not recieved although sent.
If you send an email and it does not recieve it bounces back as not sent
So did Dundee send it to the wrong address if it never pinged back.
Thats how emails work the address is either valid or not

so who did they send it to what address
if it is the wrong address then it was not recieved
if it was the wrong formation or invalid address it would ping back
Bullshit
Click to expand...
2 e-mail options or fax (yes really). Stinks. The vote has no credibility yet they are still trying to get a conclusion from it. To coin an unfortunate phrase the vote is null and void. Doncaster and all who presided over this shambles have to resign or be pushed.
 
You know whit......just finish the fucking season when the fitbaw is able to resume and be done with this nonsense! Too many agenda driven chancers and bitter zoomers involved in the game here to come to any reasonable solution so no calling of the league and no prize money until the final games have been played and everything's been settled.
 
Shadow2 said:
You know whit......just finish the fucking season when the fitbaw is able to resume and be done with this nonsense! Too many agenda driven chancers and bitter zoomers involved in the game here to come to any reasonable solution so no calling of the league and no prize money until the final games have been played and everything's been settled.
Click to expand...
100% Shadow2,,by all means pay the friggin money now,,but it also ends now.
Cake and eat it..definitely not.

HH.
 
green sprig said:

Inverness chief on Radio Shortbread

Only thing wrong with the statement is saying he was shocked. Nothing shocking or surprising about this. We have known for years they are corrupt.
www.followfollow.com www.followfollow.com
Click to expand...
When Forfar came out and said that the prize money to thenm is three bob the game was up. clubs looking for clarity to allow them to prepare for next season, Forfar have five players with contracts to be given and sorted, the bottom line is 30 games played out a possible 38 and 13 points not even close to been caught, there is not going to be a challenge, based on performance there is not going to be teams lower down the division taking points at Celtic park, Celtic were rattling goals in also v the St Mirrens etc, the huns were basing their maths on beating Celtic twice and winning their game in hand and going unbeaten and with Celtic expected to drop another 5 points to enable the huns to overcome Celtics advantage in goals which would be a point if they fropped 13 points and were level. Fantasy football.
 
green sprig said:
100% Shadow2,,by all means pay the friggin money now,,but it also ends now.
Cake and eat it..definitely not.

HH.
Click to expand...
Might be a better laugh now, show the evidence and wee Robertson off the SPFL due to conflict of interest in decisions now regards allegations made. So if Robertson is on the board then he knows the whistleblower, so produce the evidence, and protect the whistleblower they claim responsible. Is this another show us the deeds moment.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Members online

Total: 359 (members: 6, guests: 353)

Latest posts

Share this page

Back
Top