Scottish Independence

I have been reading aboot trade negotiations with the US post Brexit. American companies want to force their GM foods, milk, dairy products and beef from hormone fed cattle, upon us. These are banned under current EU rules. The EU stopped these American companies from poisoning us the way they poisoned America. Do you think the Tories will do what's best for Joe Public or do what's best for business men?
We are about to go from EU employment law to Tory employment laws.
EU law or Tory law, I know what I prefer.
God help us if ever American health care companies make "donations" to Tory election campaigns. The healthcare adverts on TV there are shocking. They have adverts that say, Socialised health care is evil and kills people, bad mouthing the NHS and so on. Mrs Rb was outraged and defended the NHS to anyone who would listen.

Never mind ah that pish though, mon the Celts, pump St Mirren, Sevco beaten to a pulp by Killie. Defoe and the hefty "journalist/player" Boyd pick up career ending injuries after a clash of egos on the plastic pitch.
4-0 to Celtic tonight is my prediction
HH
Rich
Don't know about you Richybhoy, but I've never seen a tory front bencher, pictured with a bag of messages coming out of Iceland, a future trade deal with the yanks will see us done up like a kipper on two fronts, if it's Trump or whatever crackpot follows him, it's America first when it comes to any deal, secondly, Maggie May has made such a great job of the withdrawal agreement, by the time we do leave we will be on our knees begging for a deal, the Yanks will have us for breakfast.
I would be advising anyone who will listen, for the benefit of their own health, to be very picky when it comes to filling your shopping basket, especially meat products, they are injecting so many steroids into their animals that soon the cattle will be making their own way across the pond by swimming.
When it comes to any pharma deals, we will be expected to meet targets for buying medicines, failure to meet these targets will see penalties imposed on us, the Thatcherite Blair already pushed us further down the road to privatisation in the NHS, any deal with the Yanks will push us further down that road. Big problems coming mate.
 
I think there's a real cross section of the Celtic Support on this forum...so

If there was another referendum on independence would you vote to stay or to go.....and why would you vote that way.

As an addendum to this topic...do you trust the SNP to act in your best interests?......or if voting yes.....it's a matter of independence first then we'll sort out which party should get the nod after independence has been won.
 
Are the charges against Alex Salmond a British smear campaign?
Is this his punishment for the breakup of the British state?
Or is this punishment for working for the Russian state broadcaster RT?
The British are brutal and devious, evil if ye prefer, and I put nothing past them.
HH Rich
First thing that struck me n aw. Roger Casement all over again. Saying that it's A LOT of accusations to conjure up.
 
As with most countries involved in seeking independence, there is the serious challenge of civil war. The question, I feel, should be, is independence worth the inevitable bloodshed? How many would be prepared to take up arms and kill? I won't answer that question.
 
Totally against independence. Truth is that we are subsidized to the tune of approximately £1,200 for every person that lives here as we can't generate enough ourselves. Yes it sticks in my throat to admit it.
Last time we took a vote it was largely based in income from oil. The price went through the floor.
The SNP bang on about Scotland staying in the EU. Impossible as we would essentially be a new country and if we applied it could take years for our application to be considered as per their rules.
Nicola Sturgeon is only out to make a name for herself. Cannot stand her.
HH?
 
Totally against independence. Truth is that we are subsidized to the tune of approximately £1,200 for every person that lives here as we can't generate enough ourselves. Yes it sticks in my throat to admit it.
Last time we took a vote it was largely based in income from oil. The price went through the floor.
The SNP bang on about Scotland staying in the EU. Impossible as we would essentially be a new country and if we applied it could take years for our application to be considered as per their rules.
Nicola Sturgeon is only out to make a name for herself. Cannot stand her.
HH?

Sorry Stevie but the English tax payer has never ever been out of pocket because of Scotland. We more than pay our way. Why do you think they fought so hard and told so many lies to keep us part of their Union? Do you think it's because they like giving us money?
Do not believe the lies of the English media or the pro Union Scottish media. If we were costing them money they would have ditched us years ago.
Hail Hail
Rich
 
Sorry Stevie but the English tax payer has never ever been out of pocket because of Scotland. We more than pay our way. Why do you think they fought so hard and told so many lies to keep us part of their Union? Do you think it's because they like giving us money?
Do not believe the lies of the English media or the pro Union Scottish media. If we were costing them money they would have ditched us years ago.
Hail Hail
Rich

Same for me Richybhoy, anybody who believes the answer to all our problems is the Status Quo, then they shouldn't hold their breath waiting for things to change.
 
Westminster and Europe are imo two cheeks of the same arse, true sovereignty means we would be free from the two of them, as you alluded to earlier, getting oil without deep sea drilling has maybe a decade or two left, deep sea drilling is expensive and dangerous and very risky for the environment.
The Norwegians didn't piss their oil revenues against the wall, putting money away every year for a rainy day.
They also have the best vessels in Europe to get rid of the ageing rigs and guess what, they will be making a healthy profit for their services. You are spot on when you talk about the huge benefits in renewable energy, it's the greed of the UK government that is keeping this at bay, who cares about pollution when the oil revenues are coming in.
I've long accepted that when Scotland becomes independant we will be applying for European membership on day one, while hardly filling me with joy, the fact that we are no longer ruled by the warmongering monsters of Westminster will make it easier to swallow, but the only way we will get a deal is to give up sovereignty over our waters for fishing rights.
I laugh at UK fishermen complaining about Europe and fishing rights, these were given away in the 70's by the extremely dodgy Ted Heath.
Hats off to the Norsemen, B.......

Forget this nonsense about the Swiss being the Neutrals. They're tied up in far too many banking trysts.

The true neutral country of Europe is Norway and they have built up a huge cash deposit without having heavy industry to sustain them. They have succeeded by forming alliances independent of the EU and being at the sharp end of the infrastructure in oil and shipping.

Quietly going about their business without having to be accountable to anyone but themselves. The triage they have formed with their neighbours means they trade at cost and while there is genuine wealth among the elite of their population, it is nowhere near as extreme as the wealth divide which exists here.

They have also embraced migration and are turning a profit in regions that were uninhabitable not so long ago.

It's not a transferable model though. This has been an ongoing project for at least two centuries and it was no overnight success.

Like yourself, B........I would happily accept any hardship as long as we weren't exposed to the influence of America, Russia, China or England
Totally against independence. Truth is that we are subsidized to the tune of approximately £1,200 for every person that lives here as we can't generate enough ourselves. Yes it sticks in my throat to admit it.
Last time we took a vote it was largely based in income from oil. The price went through the floor.
The SNP bang on about Scotland staying in the EU. Impossible as we would essentially be a new country and if we applied it could take years for our application to be considered as per their rules.
Nicola Sturgeon is only out to make a name for herself. Cannot stand her.
HH?
That's the problem though, Stevie.

The union-facing media have painted it as an SNP thing and it then came down to a popularity contest.

I don't have any time for Sturgeon, but independence to me would only be the first step in getting shot of her and reclaiming our country.

We would have to take a bit of shrapnel and quite a few hits. There probably won't be any signs of real progress in our lifetime, but if we plant the seeds now, there is a chance that our grandchildren will be in a position to take the country forward in future.

The EU may be fairly benevolent to Scotland, as it gives it some kind of foothold on the island and keep tabs on English relationships with the US, Saudis and Israelis
 
Are the charges against Alex Salmond a British smear campaign?
Is this his punishment for the breakup of the British state?
Or is this punishment for working for the Russian state broadcaster RT?
The British are brutal and devious, evil if ye prefer, and I put nothing past them.
HH Rich
Spot on - tried to destroy him because of both Scottish independence but slightly more for hin going on RT and telling the truth.
 
Where to start? OK, are we better independent or not? All I can say is the atrocities of Britain's colonial past still haunts. It wasn't just Englishmen but Scotsmen and Welsh too. We are as they say all tainted with the same brush. Now not for a moment I'm saying Scots where worse, but they were at least equal to their English peers. If only we could have split in those days we'd be a successful nation without any baggage re England. But times moved on and it is harder to come by now, mason and orange votes not forgetting those Catholic voters who wish to remain. Personally from my own viewpoint I'd vote for a full Republic with no attachments to England whatsoever. Remember Eamon de Valera who gave up the North for the Irish Republic. Still battling yet to get the United Ireland the people deserve. Not want to be going down the route of still having the monarchy as figureheads.. HH ☘️☘️
 
Hats off to the Norsemen, B.......

Forget this nonsense about the Swiss being the Neutrals. They're tied up in far too many banking trysts.

The true neutral country of Europe is Norway and they have built up a huge cash deposit without having heavy industry to sustain them. They have succeeded by forming alliances independent of the EU and being at the sharp end of the infrastructure in oil and shipping.

Quietly going about their business without having to be accountable to anyone but themselves. The triage they have formed with their neighbours means they trade at cost and while there is genuine wealth among the elite of their population, it is nowhere near as extreme as the wealth divide which exists here.

They have also embraced migration and are turning a profit in regions that were uninhabitable not so long ago.

It's not a transferable model though. This has been an ongoing project for at least two centuries and it was no overnight success.

Like yourself, B........I would happily accept any hardship as long as we weren't exposed to the influence of America, Russia, China or England

That's the problem though, Stevie.

The union-facing media have painted it as an SNP thing and it then came down to a popularity contest.

I don't have any time for Sturgeon, but independence to me would only be the first step in getting shot of her and reclaiming our country.

We would have to take a bit of shrapnel and quite a few hits. There probably won't be any signs of real progress in our lifetime, but if we plant the seeds now, there is a chance that our grandchildren will be in a position to take the country forward in future.

The EU may be fairly benevolent to Scotland, as it gives it some kind of foothold on the island and keep tabs on English relationships with the US, Saudis and Israelis


You wouldn't believe the amount of people during the scottish referendum who I was asking why they were voting to stay in the UK, thought that a vote for independence meant a life of Nationalism, I was gobsmacked, even when I explained that if the country voted yes a general election would be first thing on the agenda after we all sobered up, they couldn't see it, they thought everybody voting yes was a nationalist and the SNP would reign over Scotland.
We bottled it as a nation, and I'm sorry, but I now want chaos through a hard brexit like this country has never seen in modern history, England will become intolerant after brexit, the sooner we leave her to her own devices the better mate.
After living through years of tory rule 1979 to the present day (New Labour to me were as right wing as they come) I feel we can take the shrapnel wounds you mentioned, middle age folks like ourselves SP, may not reap the full benefits of an independent Scotland and I don't expect to, but I might relax a bit more if when I see the youngsters in this country have a better chance than we did mate.
 
You wouldn't believe the amount of people during the scottish referendum who I was asking why they were voting to stay in the UK, thought that a vote for independence meant a life of Nationalism, I was gobsmacked, even when I explained that if the country voted yes a general election would be first thing on the agenda after we all sobered up, they couldn't see it, they thought everybody voting yes was a nationalist and the SNP would reign over Scotland.
We bottled it as a nation, and I'm sorry, but I now want chaos through a hard brexit like this country has never seen in modern history, England will become intolerant after brexit, the sooner we leave her to her own devices the better mate.
After living through years of tory rule 1979 to the present day (New Labour to me were as right wing as they come) I feel we can take the shrapnel wounds you mentioned, middle age folks like ourselves SP, may not reap the full benefits of an independent Scotland and I don't expect to, but I might relax a bit more if when I see the youngsters in this country have a better chance than we did mate.
 
You wouldn't believe the amount of people during the scottish referendum who I was asking why they were voting to stay in the UK, thought that a vote for independence meant a life of Nationalism, I was gobsmacked, even when I explained that if the country voted yes a general election would be first thing on the agenda after we all sobered up, they couldn't see it, they thought everybody voting yes was a nationalist and the SNP would reign over Scotland.
We bottled it as a nation, and I'm sorry, but I now want chaos through a hard brexit like this country has never seen in modern history, England will become intolerant after brexit, the sooner we leave her to her own devices the better mate.
After living through years of tory rule 1979 to the present day (New Labour to me were as right wing as they come) I feel we can take the shrapnel wounds you mentioned, middle age folks like ourselves SP, may not reap the full benefits of an independent Scotland and I don't expect to, but I might relax a bit more if when I see the youngsters in this country have a better chance than we did mate.
You've nailed it, B, that echoes my own sentiments exactly.

I'm even up for some 3-day weeks and industrial meltdown.

New Labour betrayed every person even marginally left-of-centre in the entire country. I initially thought it was a cunning ruse to make Labour more palatable to middle-england, but that notion was shattered with Brown's tax-breaks for Murdoch, Eccleston and the billionaire brigade.

I don't even want to consider the Unholy alliance with dubya.

Independence has to be a blank canvas. It has to be an opportunity for fresh ideas and big ambition.

The biggest sin would be to accept party politics as they currently exist.

There is talent within the country and that talent extends to non-Scots. We should embrace external influences if they are conducive to our country's development and we can invest ourselves in science and education instead of being a satellite state for foreign land grabbers.

Chaos is the only currency for change, a microscopic example could be evidenced with Celtic in 94. Without the general havoc created by the fans, the old custodians would have eventually buried us. It was that chaos that unsettled Uncle Jack and others and created a pathway for the rebels.
 
Back
Top